Wendy Alexander does or doesn’t want Scottish Independence?
Anyone who’s read any of my previous posts will know I’m a fervent Scottish nationalist, but I try not to force my opinion on others since I know how much I hate it when JW’s come knocking on my door.
BUT, this whole thing with Wendy Alexander and the Scottish Labour Party is cracking me right up like a walnut hit with a hammer.
Here’s the situation for those of you who don’t know Scotland well. First, we don’t all wear kilts, secondly, for 300 odd years we’ve been in an ‘Act of Union’ with the English and Welsh. For the last few years the SNP has been waging a political battle for Scottish independence. Up until very recently the other major political parties have been against independence and for continuing the union.
Devolution gave us our first Scottish parliament and last year Alex Salmond and the SNP won the Scottish elections and formed a government, and in the process kicking Labour squarely out of the sandpit for a lot of their own long time supporters.
My own father is a Scottish nationalist but always voted Labour coz he was in the union and Labour was always the party of the the unions, but last election he switched to the SNP, he got a bit sick of people like Blair with their snobby accents and flash cars trying to tell him how to live his life.
Anyway, getting back to Wendy ALexander, well she’s the current leader of the opposition at Holyrood (our Scottish parliament) and is supposed to take instructions from Labour down in Westminster but just recently she came out in favour of an early referendum on Scottish independence. Supposedly she wants to preserve the United Kingdom and thinks an early referendum will oppose independence.
To me and my muddled thoughts this can only mean the mainstream parties are starting to get worried about the depth of feeling growing in Scotland over the independence issue, and that gives me a warm glow inside. The SNP have stated Scotland isn’t ready for a referendum, they want another year or two in power to prove themselves to the Scottish people, well I agree completely.
Unfortunately for Wendy Alexander she’s fallen out of favour with Gordon Brown, also a Scot, but who would prefer the independence issue would just go away.
I’m thinking this issue is going to haunt the Westminster Labour party well into Brown’s term as Prime Minister, it almost seems to me like Scottish Labour have realised the people of Scotland want independence and they want to distance themselves from the UK Labour party and set themselves up a credible alternative to the SNP in a post-independence Scotland.
I could be wrong, but if the First Minister and his cabinet ever read this I want you to know you have the support of one Scot in staying your hand. Don’t let Labour rush you into something until you feel the time is really right.
Comments
Comment from fat bastard
Time: May 10, 2008, 6:44 am
I’ve traveled over to the UK (mostly England) many times in the past ten years. I’m always fascinated with the way that the English, Scottish and Welsh approach this issue. It always seems to be from an emotional perspective. I’ve never heard anyone discuss it from the financial or political side. Is it really in Scotland’s best interest to be independent?
Comment from rich
Time: May 10, 2008, 7:50 am
I’m from England - I love the scottish people and have visited and hiked in the highlands I think it’s a great place.
I am personally in favour of the UK, but calling it the united kingdom suggests that it is still based on a kingdom, perhaps something more accurate would be the United Isles
Comment from David Webb (Photographer and Computer Geek)
Time: May 10, 2008, 9:12 pm
I’m not very knowlegable on English politics, but this explains a lot for me. Thanks!
Comment from Caledonian Jim
Time: May 11, 2008, 8:02 am
The longer the SNP government in Scotland goes on, with Alex Salmond using every opportunity to create genuine differences between Scotland and England, the more independence becomes likely . He is therefore right to resist an early referendum which is simply a ruse by Labour to try and restore flagging support .
Labour may try and hold a referendum on the same day as the next general election, hoping to link support for Labour to opposition to independence . In the current political climate however, that might well prove to be a very dangerous strategy . In any event, although I live in England, being a Scot, the day we get independence I’ll be in Edinburgh lining up for my new passport !
Comment from admin
Time: May 11, 2008, 8:35 am
Too right Jim, I’ve travelled around England and its a great place but its not Scotland, and even though I may well split my time between Scotland and the continent in the future, it’ll be Scotland I call home. Bring on the Scottish passport.
Comment from Make a pound
Time: May 11, 2008, 3:08 pm
hey me again where in scotland you from am about 8 mile from edinburgh ![]()



Comment from C K
Time: May 9, 2008, 9:23 am
I came to know about the relationship between Scotland and England only after watching Braveheart in my teens. I know, I know… but please forgive me for my ignorance.
I would think that it’ll be a pity if the Scots were to lose their unique identity. Well, you can count on a Singaporean’s support on that issue.
Cheers!